"He can't breathe": a Palestinian Eric Garner
by Kathryn Shihadah
Hebron is an ancient city in the West Bank of the Occupied Palestinian Territories with a population of about 220,000 Palestinians and less than 1,000 Jewish settlers.
About 1,000 Israeli soldiers are charged with “keeping the peace,” a job at which they have consistently failed - or so one would suppose, given that for 22 years the city has been obliged to host the TIPH (Temporary International Presence in Hebron).
TIPH observers were mandated by the UN as part of the Oslo Accords to witness and chronicle abuse of Palestinian residents by both Israeli settlers - who reside on the land illegally - and Israeli soldiers.
During their two decades in Hebron, TIPH documented about 40,000 separate cases of abuse, some of which may be war crimes. When their report was leaked in December, Israel’s sin was laid bare for all to see.
No one lifted a finger - except for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
Netanyahu did not launch an investigation into the soldiers’ actions or call out the settlers. He fired TIPH.
“We will not allow the continuation of an international force that acts against us,” Netanyahu said with a straight face. (It’s an election year.)
Still we yawned - except for the United Nations Security Council, which attempted to pass a resolution expressing “regret” at Israel’s decision. The US vetoed it.
Cue the cricket noises - we’re still indifferent.
Really? Let’s review.
This is 40,000 - FORTY THOUSAND - cases of abuse in 20 years. That’s about 5 cases PER DAY.
And here’s the kicker: this is 5 cases a day WHILE INTERNATIONAL OBSERVERS WERE PRESENT.
And now the international observers are gone.
What will it take for us to awaken from our coma of compliance?
Echoes of Eric Garner
In New York City on July 17th, 2014, police approached a black man named Eric Garner and accused him of illegally selling cigarettes.
Garner protested, asserting that “every time you see me you want to mess with me." I’m tired of it…I’m minding my business. Please just leave me alone.”
Garner was put in a chokehold and wrestled to the ground. His last words, “I can’t breathe,” became a rallying cry for black lives.
In Hebron, Palestine on May 17th, 2017, Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) surrounded M as he walked through a market. He was about to join the roughly 40% of the male Palestinian population who, since 1967, have been detained or arrested.
M struggled to break free from the crowd of soldiers; when he was put in a chokehold, he struggled for air. The international observer who was filming the incident said again and again, “he can’t breathe.”
When he was taken away by the Israeli soldiers, Christian Peacemaker Teams reports that he was blindfolded, handcuffed, and” threatened with death if his younger brother didn’t turn himself in.” M’s older brother was already in prison.
The US vetoed a UN resolution expressing regret over the dismissal of those who would bear witness to this brutality.
WATCH THIS VIDEO OF M’S ARREST. THIS IS WHAT HAPPENED FIVE TIMES A DAY FOR 20 YEARS IN THE PRESENCE OF INTERNATIONAL OBSERVERS.
(Search YouTube if you think this was a one-time incident.)
A few comparisons
Eric Garner’s arrest and M’s were similar in many ways; they also had significant differences. Here are just a few observations, in no particular order:
Both men were seriously outnumbered and overpowered (although only the israeli forces were armed to the teeth).
Both men had experienced a lifetime of harassment and humiliation - profiling, prejudice, brutality, lack of opportunity. That can get to you after a while.
Both incidents were witnessed by local crowds (and Garner’s killing was watched all over the world) - and those witnesses would not forget. To witness such ruthless injustice is to be changed forever - and not in a warm, fuzzy way.
Both incidents were filmed - yet their abusers were not held accountable. Eric Garner’s killer, officer Daniel Pantaleo, went scot free although he had a pattern of “allegedly unlawful, racially motivated arrests.” Israeli soldiers are scarcely reprimanded for even the most cold-blooded attacks: witness Elor Azaria, who, in another filmed Hebron incident, shot an incapacitated Palestinian man in the head at close range. He received a 9-month sentence, but became a folk hero. (A video can be found here - it’s graphic but pixellated.)
While Eric Garner’s death resulted in plans to “retrain [NYPD] officers on the use of force,” M’s incident (which thankfully he survived) drew no comment from Israel - probably because it’s so ordinary. (After Elor Azaria’s manslaughter conviction, PM Netanyahu called for a pardon; Azaria served all of 9 months.) Retraining would be a great idea for both the NYPD and the IDF, what they really need is a heart transplant.
Both men could be criticized for resisting arrest - but regardless, they did not deserve the harsh treatment they received.
Both of these incidents demand justice and a system-wide overhaul - but in both cases, not enough people care.
“Not playing games”
The chatty IDF soldier on the video of M’s arrest told the international observer who was filming, “We don’t play games” as he marched the gasping young man to the jeep (in case the combat helmet, body armor, walkie-talkie, and other accoutrements didn’t tip her off).
Rev. Al Sharpton’s statement at Garner’s funeral would apply equally to M’s case and the other 4 incidents in Hebron that day, and 5 the next day and the next day. He exclaimed,
Let's not play games with this. You don't need no training to stop choking a man saying 'I can't breathe.' You don't need no cultural orientation to stop choking a man saying 'I can't breathe.' You need to be prosecuted and you need to be put away.
Indeed, these are not games. These are lives. They matter.